Currently work_on_task uses spawnProcess which doesn't capture errors. If the orchestrator crashes immediately (missing command, permission error, etc), Ava doesn't know and reports success.
Should either: 1. Use createProcess and check exit code after a short delay 2. Have orchestrator write a 'started' sentinel file 3. Check for log file creation 4. Use a different spawn mechanism that can report early failures
CHANGES REQUESTED: Looking at this code review task, let me analyze the changes against the requirements.
Task Analysis
The task asks to handle orchestrator spawn failures gracefully. The current code used
spawnProcesswhich doesn't capture errors. The task suggested several approaches: 1. Use createProcess and check exit code after a short delay 2. Have orchestrator write a 'started' sentinel file 3. Check for log file creation 4. Use a different spawn mechanismCode Review
Does it accomplish the task?
Yes - the implementation uses approach #1:
createProcesswith a 500ms delay to check if the process exits early with a failure code. This catches:Are there any bugs or issues?
The implementation looks solid:
try @SomeExceptionto catch spawn failuresnew_session = Trueto detach the process(_, _, _, ph)ignores stdin/stdout/stderr handles which is fine since they're set toNoStreamOne minor concern: if the orchestrator exits with
ExitSuccessimmediately, it's reported as success. This is noted as "suspicious but ok" in the comment, which seems reasonable.Did lint/build/test pass?
1. Unused
{-# LANGUAGE DeriveGeneric #-}pragma 2. Suggestion to use</instead of<$>on line 45These are warnings/suggestions, not errors. The unused pragma and the
<$>vs</style issue are minor and don't affect correctness.Is the code clean and following conventions?
<|operator (project's convention for$)spawnOrchestratorhelper functionLint Issues
The lint warnings should probably be fixed: 1. Remove the unused
DeriveGenericpragma 2. ChangeWorkOnTaskArgs <$> v .: "task_id"toWorkOnTaskArgs </ (v .: "task_id")These are minor style issues but the lint tool explicitly calls them out.
The implementation is correct and accomplishes the task well. However, the lint warnings should be addressed before merging: 1. Remove the unused
{-# LANGUAGE DeriveGeneric #-}pragma 2. Use</instead of<$>as suggested by hlint (line 45)